Tradewater Appraisal & RealtyAppraisal · Land Surveying · Western KY

Home › Ask the Appraiser › Can I use my mortgage appraisal for an estate, divorce or tax appeal?

Can I use my mortgage appraisal for an estate, divorce or tax appeal?

Short answer: Usually not as-is. A mortgage appraisal is prepared for the lender, for a lending decision, with a value as of a date set for that loan. An estate, a divorce or a tax appeal usually involves a different client, a different purpose and often a different date of value. The better path is to order an appraisal for the use you actually have.

Answer by Scott D. Kelley, Kentucky Certified General Appraiser #4265. General information, not legal or tax advice, and not an appraisal of any property.

Who is a mortgage appraisal actually for?

The lender. The Appraisal Foundation's Appraisal Standards Board notes that "in most mortgage financing assignments, the borrower is not typically the client or an intended user." Federal rules still let you see it: under Regulation B, a lender must give an applicant a copy of all appraisals and other written valuations developed for an application for credit secured by a first lien on a dwelling. Having a copy is useful, but it doesn't make the report one that was prepared for you, your attorney, a court or the PVA.

Why does the date of value matter?

Different uses need a value as of different dates:

A mortgage appraisal answers the lender's question as of the lender's date. Unless that happens to match your use, it answers a different question.

Is my mortgage appraisal useless, then?

No. It can be helpful background, such as a record of the home's size and features at the time. Share it with your attorney, CPA or the new appraiser. Just don't count on it being accepted in place of an appraisal done for your purpose. Whoever will rely on the value decides what they'll accept, whether that's a court, the IRS, a PVA appeal board or your servicer.

Can the same appraiser do the new appraisal?

Often, yes. The Appraisal Standards Board has said that, as with any assignment, an appraiser "might be able to use information and analyses developed for a previous assignment," while staying mindful of confidentiality obligations to the earlier client. The new appraisal is its own assignment. Its result isn't decided in advance; it depends on the facts and sales as of the new date of value.

What should I tell the appraiser when I call?

An independent appraiser doesn't advocate for a number. We can't promise a value or a result for any estate, case, appeal or loan.

To order, call Tradewater Appraisal at 270-667-4216 (Mon–Thu 8 AM–4 PM, Fri 8 AM–12 PM CT) or use the order form. Tradewater Appraisal, 114 N Broadway Ave, Providence KY 42450.

Quick answers

Can I use my mortgage appraisal for an estate, divorce or tax appeal?

Usually not as-is. A mortgage appraisal is prepared for the lender, for a lending decision. Other uses usually involve a different client, purpose and date of value, so order an appraisal for the use you actually have.

Who is a mortgage appraisal for?

The lender. The Appraisal Standards Board notes that in most mortgage financing assignments the borrower is not typically the client or an intended user. Under Regulation B, the lender must give you a copy of appraisals developed for a first-lien home loan application.

Why does the date of value matter?

Each use needs a value as of a particular date. Federal estate tax values property at the date of death (or an elected alternate valuation date), Kentucky assesses property as of January 1 each year, and in a divorce your attorney can tell you which date the case needs.

Can the same appraiser appraise the property again?

Often, yes. An appraiser may be able to use information and analyses from an earlier assignment, subject to confidentiality obligations. The new appraisal is its own assignment, and its result isn't decided in advance.

What should I tell the appraiser when I order?

Who the appraisal is for and who will rely on it, what it's for, the date of value you need, the address and county, and any earlier appraisal or survey you have. Call Tradewater Appraisal at 270-667-4216.

More questions

All questions · Find your county

Order an appraisal

Order an Appraisal

Or call 270-667-4216 / email admin@tradewaterrealty.com with the address, county, purpose and timeline.

Scott D. Kelley · KY Certified General Appraiser #4265 · verify license

Call 270-667-4216Email Scott