Tradewater Appraisal & RealtyAppraisal · Land Surveying · Western KY

Home › Ask the Appraiser › In a divorce, should we hire one appraiser together or each hire our own?

In a divorce, should we hire one appraiser together or each hire our own?

Short answer: Either can work, and your attorneys are the right people to decide which fits your case. A single appraisal ordered jointly gives both sides one report to work from. Separate appraisals give each side its own report, which can make sense when the property is unusual or the value is disputed. Either way, the appraiser's job is the same: an independent opinion of value, not a number for one side.

Answer by Scott D. Kelley, Kentucky Certified General Appraiser #4265. General information, not legal advice, and not an appraisal of any property.

Why does it matter who hires the appraiser?

In Kentucky, the court divides marital property in a divorce (KRS 403.190). Before you order, settle three things with your attorney:

Getting this right at the start avoids paying for a report that one side, or the court, isn't comfortable relying on.

One joint appraisal: when does it fit?

A joint appraisal often fits when both sides mainly want a fair, documented number to divide or to set a buyout. Both spouses (or both attorneys) agree on the appraiser, the date of value and who provides access. Everyone gets the same report, with the comparable sales and adjustments laid out so both sides can follow the reasoning.

Two separate appraisals: when does it fit?

Separate appraisals come up when the value is genuinely disputed or the property is harder to compare, such as a farm, acreage with several houses, or a property with commercial use. Two qualified appraisers can reach different opinions, and the reports show why. Two reports also mean two fees and more time, so weigh that with your attorney. For farms and land, see our farm and land appraisals.

What if my spouse won't let the appraiser inside?

Tell your attorney first; access in a divorce is a legal question, not something the appraiser can resolve. The appraiser will state in the report what was and wasn't inspected.

The case is dragging on. Do we need a whole new appraisal?

Not always a fresh start. The Appraisal Standards Board has said an appraiser "might be able to use information and analyses developed for a previous assignment," while staying mindful of confidentiality obligations to the earlier client. A value as of a new date is still its own assignment with its own report, and its result isn't decided in advance. If you used an appraiser earlier in the case, ask them first.

What should I tell the appraiser when I call?

We don't give legal advice, and we can't promise a value or an outcome in any case.

To order, call Tradewater Appraisal at 270-667-4216 (Mon–Thu 8 AM–4 PM, Fri 8 AM–12 PM CT) or use the order form. Tradewater Appraisal, 114 N Broadway Ave, Providence KY 42450.

More questions

All questions · Find your county

Order an appraisal

Order an Appraisal

Or call 270-667-4216 / email admin@tradewaterrealty.com with the address, county, purpose and timeline.

Scott D. Kelley · KY Certified General Appraiser #4265 · verify license

Call 270-667-4216Email Scott