Home › Ask the Appraiser › Why is my farm's PVA value so much lower than an appraisal?
Why is my farm's PVA value so much lower than an appraisal?
Short answer: Often because the two numbers measure different things. Kentucky law defines an agricultural value for qualifying farmland: a use value based on what the land can produce as a farm and on sales of land bought for farming. A market-value appraisal estimates what the property would likely bring from a buyer in the open market, and that can include things a farm-use value leaves out, such as homesite, hunting, recreation or expansion demand. Neither number is "wrong"; they answer different questions.
Answer by Scott D. Kelley, Kentucky Certified General Appraiser #4265. General information, not legal or tax advice, and not an appraisal of any property.
What is "agricultural value" in Kentucky?
Most Kentucky property is assessed at fair cash value, the price it would bring at a fair voluntary sale (Kentucky Constitution § 172). Section 172A of the Constitution makes an exception: it directs the General Assembly to provide for assessing agricultural and horticultural land "according to the land's value for agricultural or horticultural use."
Kentucky's property-tax chapter (KRS 132.010) defines agricultural land to include a tract of at least 10 contiguous acres used to produce livestock, livestock products, poultry, poultry products, tobacco or other crops, including timber. It also covers land enrolled in qualifying state or federal agriculture programs.
The statute then defines agricultural value as the use value of that land, based on its income-producing capability and on comparable sales of farmland bought for farm purposes. It specifically excludes sales bought for farm expansion, better access or "other factors which inflate the purchase price beyond farm use value." Factors it lists include the mix of tillable, pasture and wooded land, soil productivity, flood risk, income-producing improvements, row-crop capability, access to all-weather roads and markets, and the farm economy.
Under KRS 132.450, the PVA assesses everything at fair cash value unless the land qualifies; when the PVA determines a tract meets the requirements, its taxable value is the agricultural value. Land under barns and other farm buildings, ponds and streams counts toward the acreage. Land used with a house, such as the lawn, drive, flower gardens or a pool, does not. The Department of Revenue's assessment manual adds that the PVA must determine both the fair cash value and the agricultural value each year for qualifying property. How to apply for agricultural value in your county is a question for your PVA office.
Why can the market value be higher?
Because buyers in western Kentucky don't only buy land to farm it. A market-value appraisal looks at what comparable properties actually sold for, and those sales can reflect:
- A homesite or a house on the property
- Hunting, timber or recreation appeal
- A neighbor paying extra to expand an operation
- Road frontage that could be split into smaller tracts
The agricultural-value definition deliberately sets those premiums aside. A market-value appraisal doesn't, because they're part of what the market pays.
Does the house count as farmland?
Not if the owner lives in it. KRS 132.450 leaves the land used with a dwelling (lawn, drive, gardens, pool and similar areas) out of the agricultural acreage. The Kentucky Department of Revenue's assessment manual says a farm residence occupied by the farm owner must be assessed at its fair cash value and isn't eligible for agricultural value. Houses used by farm managers or tenants who actually work the farm can be valued by what they contribute to the farm's income. So on a farm with a house, the PVA figure is usually a mix: agricultural value on the qualifying land, and fair cash value on the house and homesite.
The same manual notes that where a farm has little development potential, the fair cash value and the agricultural value can be nearly the same; the gap is largest for farms at the edge of towns and cities.
Which number do I need?
It depends on the use, so check with whoever will rely on the value:
- Selling or buying: market value. That's what a buyer pays. See How are farms and rural land appraised in Kentucky?
- Estate or heirs: usually market value as of the date of death; your attorney or CPA confirms. See I inherited a house. Why does its date-of-death value matter? (once live)
- Farm loan: the lender sets the appraisal requirements.
- Changing the land's use: if farmland assessed at agricultural value is converted to another use, KRS 132.454 says the changed portion is taxed at fair cash value the next tax year, and the owner must report the change to the PVA within 90 days, including copies of any appraisal made. Talk to the PVA before you split off a lot or change use.
- Property-tax questions: Kentucky lists, assesses and values property as of January 1 each year. If you think your assessment is off, start with the PVA. Our tax appeal appraisals page explains when an appraisal can help.
A low PVA figure doesn't mean the farm would sell for that, and a market-value appraisal doesn't change your assessment by itself.
What should I tell the appraiser when I call?
- What the appraisal is for (sale, estate, loan, other) and who will rely on it
- The deed, and any survey or plat (acreage on a PVA card isn't always accurate)
- How the acres break down: tillable, pasture, woods
- Improvements: homes, barns, bins, fencing, wells and ponds
- Any leases (cash rent, hunting or timber) and notes on mineral rights
We can't promise a value or any tax result. More on what goes into a farm value is on our farm and land appraisals page.
To order, call Tradewater Appraisal at 270-667-4216 (Mon–Thu 8 AM–4 PM, Fri 8 AM–12 PM CT) or use the order form. Tradewater Appraisal, 114 N Broadway Ave, Providence KY 42450.