Home › Ask the Appraiser › I inherited a house. Why does its date-of-death value matter when I sell?
I inherited a house. Why does its date-of-death value matter when I sell?
Short answer: Because it is usually your starting point for figuring any taxable gain. Under federal tax law, the basis of property you inherit is generally its fair market value on the date the owner died. When you sell, gain or loss is measured from that basis, not from what the owner originally paid. A retrospective (date-of-death) appraisal is one way to document that value. Your CPA or the estate's attorney decides what the estate and the heirs need.
Answer by Scott D. Kelley, Kentucky Certified General Appraiser #4265. General information, not legal or tax advice, and not an appraisal of any property.
What does "basis" have to do with the appraisal?
Federal law (26 U.S.C. § 1014) says the basis of property acquired from a decedent is generally its fair market value at the date of death. The IRS puts it in plain terms: the basis of inherited property is generally the fair market value on the date of death, whether or not the executor files an estate tax return. If the executor files an estate tax return and elects the alternate valuation date, that later date's value is used instead.
So if the house sells for more than the date-of-death value, the difference is generally gain. If it sells for less, the difference may be a loss, and whether a loss counts depends on your situation. How any of it is reported is a question for your CPA.
Can an appraiser really value a house as of a date in the past?
Yes. That's a retrospective appraisal (the basics are on What is a date-of-death appraisal?). The appraiser studies sales that happened around the date of death, not today's market, and values the property as it was on that date.
That last part is where heirs can help most. A house often changes after the owner dies: it sits empty, gets cleaned out, repaired or remodeled, or loses an outbuilding. The appraiser needs to know what the property was like on the date of death, so gather:
- Photos from around that time, if anyone has them (family photos often show rooms and the exterior)
- A list of anything repaired, replaced, added or removed since then, with rough dates
- Any damage that happened after the date of death (storm, freeze, vandalism)
- The deed, and any survey or plat
Should we wait until the house sells?
That depends on the estate, so ask your attorney or CPA. Some points that come up:
- The sale price is a different date. A sale months later reflects the market and the property's condition at that later time.
- The value can be supported by sales around the date of death, even when the appraisal is done later. Records of the home's condition at that date make it easier.
- Land and farms take more work. If the estate includes acreage, see our farm and land appraisals. If the land will be split among heirs, a survey may come first (Do I need a survey to divide land?).
Can we use the appraisal from the owner's last refinance?
Usually not as-is. It was prepared for a lender, as of a different date. We explain why in Can I use my mortgage appraisal for an estate, divorce or tax appeal? It can still be useful background for the new appraiser.
What should I tell the appraiser when I call?
- That it's for an estate, and the date of death (or the date your CPA or attorney says to use)
- Who the client is (the executor, the estate's attorney or the heirs) and who else will rely on the report
- The property address and county
- What has changed since the date of death
- Who can give access to the property
An independent appraiser doesn't advocate for a higher or lower number. We can't promise a value or any tax result.
To order, call Tradewater Appraisal at 270-667-4216 (Mon–Thu 8 AM–4 PM, Fri 8 AM–12 PM CT) or use the order form. Tradewater Appraisal, 114 N Broadway Ave, Providence KY 42450.