Home › Ask the Appraiser › My home's value went up. Can a new appraisal get rid of my PMI?
My home's value went up. Can a new appraisal get rid of my PMI?
Short answer: Sometimes. Federal law sets PMI cancellation rules based on your home's original value. Removing PMI because the home is worth more today is up to your loan's investor and servicer, and they set the loan-to-value limit, how long you must have had the loan, and how the value is checked. Call your servicer before you pay for anything: on some loans the servicer must get the valuation through its own system, so an appraisal you order yourself may not be used.
Answer by Scott D. Kelley, Kentucky Certified General Appraiser #4265. General information, not legal or financial advice, and not an appraisal of any property.
What's the difference between "original value" and "current value"?
The federal rules (the Homeowners Protection Act, as the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains it) work from your home's original value: generally the lower of the purchase price or the appraised value when you bought, or the appraised value at a refinance. Those rules, the 80% request and the 78% automatic end, are on our PMI removal appraisals page.
The CFPB also notes that some lenders and servicers allow removal of PMI under their own standards. That's where current value comes in: if prices have risen or you've improved the home, today's value may put your loan-to-value ratio low enough sooner.
How does the loan-to-value math work?
Loan-to-value (LTV) is your loan balance divided by the home's value.
So the appraised value matters a lot, and it isn't known until the appraisal is done. An appraiser can't promise a value that clears your servicer's limit.
What limits do investors use?
Each investor sets its own. As one example, Fannie Mae's servicing rules for a one-unit principal residence or second home allow removal based on current value when the LTV is:
- 75% or less if the loan is between two and five years old
- 80% or less if the loan is more than five years old
- 80% or less if the two-year minimum is waived because improvements you made increased the value
Fannie Mae also requires an acceptable payment record (current, no payment 30+ days late in the last 12 months, and none 60+ days late in the last 24 months).
Freddie Mac's rules for the same kind of loan use the same limits: 75% or less if the loan is between two and five years old, 80% or less after five years, and 80% or less when the two-year minimum is waived for substantial improvements. Freddie Mac also requires the loan to be current, with no payment 30+ days late in the last 12 months and none 60+ days late in the last 24 months.
Other investors and portfolio lenders can set their own terms. Your servicer can tell you who owns your loan and which rules apply.
Who orders the appraisal?
Ask your servicer before you order anything. On loans owned by the two largest investors, the servicer handles the valuation:
- Fannie Mae: the servicer must get a valuation based on an interior and exterior inspection through Fannie Mae's own servicing system.
- Freddie Mac: the servicer must verify the current value at your expense, within 120 days of your request. Usually that's an interior and exterior broker price opinion (BPO) ordered through Freddie Mac's system. A full appraisal is used when the law requires one or the servicer decides it's in your best interest, and the servicer orders it, either through Freddie Mac or from an appraiser it chooses.
So on loans like these, a report you order directly may not be accepted. Get the servicer's requirements in writing first. If your servicer does accept an appraisal you arrange, give the appraiser those requirements when you order.
Do improvements count?
They can. Fannie Mae describes value-adding improvements as renovations that substantially improve marketability and extend the property's useful life, such as kitchen or bathroom renovations or added square footage. Freddie Mac's examples include significant structural changes (including added square footage), work that required permits, adding features the home didn't have before (such as a bathtub, hardwood floors or central air), and energy-efficient replacements. Both treat routine repairs and like-for-like replacements as maintenance, not improvements. Freddie Mac also requires the BPO or appraisal to state the nature, extent and cost of the improvements and their effect on value. If you've made improvements, list them with dates for the servicer and the appraiser. Tips for appraisal day are in How to prepare for a home appraisal.
What if the value comes in lower than I hoped?
Then PMI likely stays for now, under the servicer's rules. On a servicer-ordered appraisal, questions about the value go through the servicer, much like the lender process in What can I do if my appraisal comes in low? An independent appraiser reports the value the market supports. We can't target a number to clear an LTV limit.
What should I tell the appraiser when I call?
- That it's for PMI removal, and your servicer's written requirements (who the client must be, report type, any form)
- The property address and county
- Improvements since you bought or refinanced, with dates
To order, call Tradewater Appraisal at 270-667-4216 (Mon–Thu 8 AM–4 PM, Fri 8 AM–12 PM CT) or use the order form. Tradewater Appraisal, 114 N Broadway Ave, Providence KY 42450.